Wellness Check for the Art Market at the First Half of 2025

A MARKET FINDING ITS BALANCE

Global fine art auction sales totalled $2.37 billion in the first half of 2025, according to results from Christie’s, Sotheby’s and Phillips, holding steady against the $2.36 billion recorded in the latter half of 2024. While the number of lots sold dipped by 3%, the average price per artwork climbed 4% to $281,000, indicating a market that’s prioritising quality over quantity.

These figures suggest a more deliberate market mood. While volume has tapered, committed collectors are still willing to spend, especially on works that resonate personally or carry strong long-term value. The shift away from speculative buying signals a more selective approach, where quality, provenance and emotional connection matter more than hype. That said, the market remains well below the highs of 2022, when average prices exceeded $550,000. Today, both buyers and sellers are operating with clear eyes and more grounded expectations.

DIFFERENT PRICE LEVELS TELL DIFFERENT STORIES

Market performance in H1 2025 has been anything but uniform, with distinct trends emerging across different price tiers:

• Top End ($5M+): The ultra-high end remains under pressure. Despite an increase in the number of major works brought to auction, total sales in this tier fell 14% to $887 million, and the average price declined by nearly a third. Appetite for trophy works hasn’t vanished, but collectors at this level are negotiating more aggressively or opting for the discretion of private sales.
• Upper-Mid Range ($1M-$5M): Momentum is building in this segment, where sales climbed 18% to $758 million. A 17% rise in lots sold suggests renewed confidence among buyers seeking a balance between status and value, often favouring historically significant works or rising blue-chip names.
• Mid-Tier ($500K-$1M): This bracket continues to gain traction, with a 23% lift in both volume and value. Demand here is driven by established collectors and institutions targeting quality works with room for future growth.
• Lower Market (Under $500K): While sales volume declined by 5%, average prices rose 5%, nudging overall value slightly higher. This points to a selective but engaged base of younger or first-time collectors who are favouring accessibly priced works with strong storytelling, provenance or cultural cachet.

 A CHANGE IN MOMENTUM, BUT NOT QUITE A COMEBACK

One of the clearest signs of market sentiment is how often works outperform their estimates. In the first half of 2025, 62% of paintings sold above their pre-sale estimates, while 10% landed within range and 28% fell short. Among those that surpassed expectations, the median result was 40% above estimate, a strong signal of competitive demand when the right work meets the right buyer.

Still, the pace feels more deliberate. Today’s collectors are doing their homework, weighing value more carefully and bidding with precision. Sellers, in turn, are adapting to a more level-headed landscape where aggressive bidding wars are the exception, not the norm.

LOOKING AHEAD: WHY NOW IS A GOOD TIME TO INVEST IN ART 

With prices levelling out and bidding dynamics returning to a more considered pace, the current market presents a compelling window for both seasoned collectors and new entrants. This is a moment for strategic acquisitions, less driven by market noise and more by long-term vision.

Robert Indiana, The Garden of Love, 1992, Edition of 100 

Several segments stand out as particularly promising:

• Post-War & Contemporary Masters ($1M-$5M): This category continues to deliver steady growth, offering historical weight without the volatility of Ultra-Contemporary names. Works by artists like Andy Warhol, George Condo and Roy Lichtenstein remain highly sought-after for their institutional relevance and lasting cultural impact.
• Established Contemporary Artists with Institutional Momentum: Figures such as Banksy, Damien Hirst and Jeff Koons are seeing recalibrated pricing, creating attractive entry points. Backed by major museum shows and global recognition, these artists combine cultural visibility with long-term collector confidence.
• Underrepresented & Rediscovered Talent: The market is undergoing a genuine shift, with increased demand for artists historically sidelined by the mainstream. From the enduring appeal of Yayoi Kusama to rising interest in artists like Robert Indiana, this space is rich in cultural weight and future upside.
• Mid-Tier Blue-Chip Works ($50K-$250K): Artworks in this bracket by names such as David Hockney and Andy Warhol offer accessibility without compromising on pedigree. Liquid, resilient and proven across market cycles, these pieces offer both aesthetic and financial value. 

The art world in 2025 rewards discernment. In this more measured environment, opportunity lies not in chasing trends but in acquiring works with a deeper resonance.

For collectors looking to build with intent, now is an ideal moment to consider your next move. If you want to learn more about why now it's good time to invest in art, and why you should invest with Maddox, contact one of our expert Art Advisors below. 

Schedule a call

The value of investments can go down as well as up, and past performance is no guarantee of future performance. Return figures shown are gross; fees, including a 20% performance commission, may apply. Liquidity is not guaranteed. Terms, limitations, and withdrawal conditions apply. Minimum recommended investment is £20,000. Maddox Advisory is not FCA-regulated and does not give financial advice. Seek independent advice before investing.